Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell
An interesting book asserting that rather than just latent talent,
an individual's success is do to:
-
timing: some people are born at just the right time to take
advantage of historical watershed moments (e.g. the PC revolution)
or age-based selections (e.g. birthday cut-offs for joining sports
teams, schools, etc).
-
practice opportunities: Gladwell asserts that the "universal"
requirement for achieving expertise is 10,000 hours of
practice. Gladwell further asserts that successful individuals have
often been given abnormal opportunities to obtain that amount of
practice in a short period of time and at an early age.
-
environment: the amount of nurture and support that a person
receives from his family and community has a significant effect on
their success. This includes parents teaching their children how to
be assertive, and actively guide their own lives.
-
culture: cultural values and behaviors can have a profound effect
on an individual's level of success.
To some degree, Outliers reminded me of other recent readings:
-
In the Black Swan, Taleb asserted that individual success in
"scalable" fields was due primarily to luck and a rich-get-richer
effect. In Outliers I think Gladwell provides a compelling
explanation for that phenomenon in his focus on lucky opportunities
for obtaining expertise.
-
The StudyHacks blog ran a post on how one person successfully
entered the music industry by selecting a single nightclub to
perform at and then focused all their energy on becoming the best
performer at that venue. To me this resonated strongly with Gladwell's
assertion that opportunities for obtaining 10,000 hours of practice are
one of the keys to success.
So, there appears to be supporting opinions for some of Gladwell's
assertions. Personally, I suspect that he is on the right track.
I enjoyed the first half of the book but found the second halves
multi-generational discussion weaker as I suspect a "lucky event" can
be found in everyone's family history if you go back a few
generations.
Being a computer geek, I enjoyed the brief biographies on both Bill
Joy and Bill Gates. I had no idea that Gates had so much programming
experience before going to college. By all appearances both Bills had
rare opportunities to become expert programmers at just the right age
to ride the PC technology wave.
Some of the excerpts that I dog-earned were:
-
Page 11: … the values of the world we inhabit and the people that
we surround ourselves with have a profound effect on who we are.
-
Page 42: (regarding the assertion that 10,000 hours of practice are
required to become an expert at any particular skill) … ten
thousand hours is an enormous amount of time. It's all but
impossible to reach that number all by yourself by the time you're a
young adult. … In fact most people can only reach that number only
if they get into some kind of special program … or if they get
some kind of extraordinary opportunity that gives them the chance to
put in those hours.
-
Page 149: Those three things - autonomy, complexity, and a
connection between effort and reward - are, most people agree, the
three qualities that work has to have if it is to be satisfying.
-
Page 267: … success follows a predictable course. It is not the
brightest who succeed. … Nor is success simply the sum of
decisions and efforts we make on our own behalf. It is, rather, a
gift. Outliers are those who have been given opportunities - and who
have had the strength and presence of mind to seize them.
Upon reflection, I reduced (perhaps too far?) the book's message down
to the following three points:
-
Pick a meaningful skill and practice it as much as possible.
-
Maximize your exposure to opportunities that require the chosen
skill to be successful and provide more practice.
-
Aggressively pursue the opportunities that you come across to
extract the most value from them.
Over all a good book, and worth the time to read it.